Food Preservation

Can You Freeze Buttermilk Pie? Easy Guide to Freeze Buttermilk Pie

In this article, you will know the answer to the query “Can You Freeze Buttermilk Pie?“.

Southern desserts like buttermilk pie are classics. The creamy dessert is laced with vanilla and appeals to everyone.

The most common method for making this pie is to simply use a store-bought frozen coconut pie crust and add ingredients straight from the can.

Having buttermilk pie freeze so well is the best part about it.

It does not matter whether you want something easy to serve as a dessert or if you just want to save time by preparing something on a day when you can’t serve it, this delicious recipe is the solution you have been looking for.

Buttermilk pie can be stored in the freezer for up to 3 months; however, it is best to thaw the pie overnight in the refrigerator.

Make sure to serve this frozen delight as soon as possible after removing it from the freezer, or else it will lose its creamy texture and won’t taste nearly as good.

In this article, we will give you some great tips on how to make buttermilk pie and how to freeze it.

Choosing a Good Recipe for Buttermilk Pie

It is quite simple to make this spectacular dessert.

There are three main ingredients you’ll need to make buttermilk pie: buttermilk, vanilla, and sugar.

If you want to add more flavors, you can even add other natural components such as lemon zest, chocolate chips, or candied pecans.

You do not have to be a professional baker or pastry chef to make buttermilk pie, which is a fantastic dessert.

Even a novice cook can follow a simple buttermilk pie recipe, and it tastes delicious.

Since frozen pie recipes are so easy to prepare, some prefer to use box mixes over-complicated frozen pie recipes.

At cookbook shops and online, it is possible to find a few high-quality recipes using box mixes.

Does Freezing Affect Buttermilk Pie?

It depends, that’s the answer.

The pie will taste great if you serve it shortly after removing it from the freezer; however, if you leave it in the freezer for more than a month or two, then there might be some quality issues with your dessert.

To avoid quality problems after thawing buttermilk pie after freezing, it is best to take precautions.

To begin with, do not let the pie sit out on the counter for longer than two hours, as it may defrost slightly and change color and flavor.

As long as you keep it frozen until you are ready to serve it, the texture and taste will not change.

In addition, keep the pie as cold as possible in a container large enough to hold the entire pie.

The container will remain fresh for longer if it is stored in an area with minimal temperature changes in your freezer.

Avoid bags or containers with plastic linings since they could cause your dessert to sweat and lose flavor.

An ideal container would be made from glass or metal to insulate against temperature changes while also preventing the pie from being exposed to air.

How to Freeze Buttermilk Pie?

In case you have chosen a great buttermilk pie recipe and are ready to freeze it, here is everything you need to know about freezing buttermilk pie:

You should prepare your frozen pie for freezing first.

Put it in a zip-close freezer bag after wrapping it in plastic wrap.

You should remove as much air from the bag as possible before closing it; otherwise, you might end up with a mess when you remove it.

You can also put a layer of wax paper between the pie and the plastic wrap so that the crust doesn’t get soggy.

After your frozen pie has been properly wrapped, it is time to put it in the freezer.

Pie containers should be stored in a part of the freezer where temperature changes are minimal, as previously mentioned.

So, the pie will maintain its quality for a longer period of time.

If you don’t label your pie, you won’t remember what’s inside.

In most cases, buttermilk pie can be frozen for at least six months, depending on the recipe.

How to Thaw and Reheat Frozen Buttermilk Pie?

These are some quick and easy steps you can use to thaw buttermilk pie:

The first step is to remove the frozen pie from the freezer.

Remove it the day before or even a few hours before serving.

After removing it from the container, wrap it tightly in a damp towel or place it in the refrigerator.

Then, just wait until it thaws. When your pie is ready for serving, it needs to be rebaked to restore its color and texture.

The process may take between 10 and 20 minutes, so plan accordingly. If you prefer, you can use the original crust or make a new one.

You can also enjoy your dessert warm after it has been reheated, just as when it was first baked.

If you would like to reheat your pie, you would bake it at 375 degrees for about 20 minutes or until it reaches an internal temperature of 190-200 degrees.

During baking, you may want to cover the edges with aluminum foil to keep moisture in and prevent over-browning.

How to Tell if Buttermilk Pie is Bad?

After you’ve frozen your pie for months, you might think it’s spoiled. If so, there are a few signs you can look for.

You should smell your pie once you open it; however, if instead of a sweet smell, your nose is greeted by an off one or even no odor at all – your pie may have gone bad.

It is a sure sign that the pie has spoiled if the filling is runny or watery when you cut it open.

Moreover, if the color of your buttermilk pie changes from pale yellow to dark brown or even green, it might be spoiled.

Most frozen desserts will keep their quality for at least six months; therefore, if you have kept the pie in the freezer for longer than six months, you probably ought to discard it and start over.

It’s always best to throw away buttermilk pie if you are not sure if it has gone bad.


You will be pleasantly surprised by how much flavor buttermilk pie adds to your family’s meals.

Making buttermilk pie from scratch is not as challenging as you might have thought. By using a great recipe for buttermilk pie and freezing it, you’ll find that it’s very easy to prepare this dessert ahead of time.

Do you have any favorite recipes for buttermilk pie? Learn how to make homemade frozen fruit desserts or more great homemade desserts to freeze.

Can You Freeze Buttermilk Pie? Easy Guide to Freeze Buttermilk Pie


15 minutes


15 minutes


30 minutes


  • Buttermilk pie
  • Air-tight containers or Ziplock bags
  • Labels and markers


  • This can be done by wrapping it in plastic wrap and placing it in a zip-top freezer bag.
  • Make sure you remove as much air from the bag as possible before closing it; otherwise, you might end up with a mess when you take it out.
  • You can also put a piece of wax paper between the pie and the plastic wrap to prevent the crust from becoming soggy.
  • With your frozen pie properly wrapped, it is time to place it in the freezer.
  • Don’t forget to label your pie so that you can remember what it contains.
  • Depending on the recipe you choose, you can freeze your buttermilk pie for up to six months.

If you want to read more about food preservation, read here: FOOD PRESERVATION.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button