How To Thicken Beef Stroganoff? Easy Guide To Thicken Beef Stroganoff?

The Russian dish beef stroganoff is probably one of the most famous dishes all over the world.

As for its origin, there are many, many theories, but we won’t go into them now.

In this article, you will know the answer to the query “How To Thicken Beef Stroganoff?“.

There is no doubt that it has been a popular dish for many years and continues to be so even today.

It is obvious that the recipe has two components: beef and cream sauce.

It’s important to strike the right balance between the two as you thicken your dish.

To prevent the meat from becoming tough and chewy, it is often thinly sliced and heated with boiling water while being cooked.

It is very easy to thicken any occasion stew or sauce by adding ingredients that thicken without compromising the taste.

To do this, one needs to understand how things thicken and what ingredients cause this.

The purpose of this article is to discuss different methods of thickening and serving beef stroganoff.

How to Make a Perfect Beef Stroganoff?

You don’t have to be an expert to make the best Beef Stroganoff.

Making a dish that will please even the most discriminating diners is as easy as following a few guidelines.

The Meat:

 If you want your dish to be flavorful and rich-looking, cook the meat in a hot liquid.

This can be done in a crockpot. Bring up to a boil the water and add the meat. Cover the meat with boiling water, and let sit for about 30 minutes.

For best results, cook on high for 2 hours or on low for 4-6 hours.

The Ingredients: 

Add any herbs and spices you like to this dish to make it your own.

In addition to substituting sour cream for cheese, you can use another kind of cheese if you wish.

Sour cream can be substituted with mozzarella or parmesan.

If you are planning to use onion powder, you may want to add small bits of sauteed onion to the meat while it is cooking.

The Sauce:

 The sour cream can’t be all used if you want a creamy sauce.

Mix equal amounts of mayonnaise and sour cream to resolve this issue.

If you combine them this way, you can achieve that rich flavor without overusing either.

The Flour:

Take the beef out of the oven and stir in a tablespoon of flour after it has been cooked.

With a whisk, mix this well and allow it to bubble up for a few minutes. Gradually add the stock, stirring constantly.

Bring the mixture to a boil once you have added all the stock and add the sour cream & mayonnaise mixture.

The Taste:

Some people believe serving this dish with spaghetti will help the sauce absorb and make it taste better.

While heating everything together to serve, you can mix in some prepared pasta or just the sauce.

Common Mistakes When Making Beef Stroganoff

There are still many mistakes people make when making Beef Stroganoff, despite the dish’s long history.

As for the meat itself, it is the first element. You should use tender beef fillets if possible, such as sirloin or rump.

People make the second mistake of overcooking their meat, which leads to a dry and tasteless mess.

Beef fillets can be avoided by sealing them in a hot liquid and cooking them on high or low for at least 2 hours.

This leaves an extremely bland dish with a lack of flavor because ground beef is used instead of steak.

Adding salt to the ground beef mixture before browning is a must if you must use ground beef.

As a substitute for mayonnaise or sour cream, people use sour cream.

When creating a smooth sauce, don’t combine both if you don’t want clumps of unblended ingredients.

Incorrectly thickening a sauce or using insufficient flour is the fifth mistake.

The meat can be cooked in a hot liquid and then removed to provide an excellent basic gravy that can be used to thicken stews or soups.

As soon as the meat has been removed from the hot liquid, add 1 tablespoon flour and 1/4 cup water.

Using a whisk, mix well and cook until bubbling.

Slowly add stock while constantly stirring to prevent lumps.

How to Thicken Beef Stroganoff?

If you are looking for ways to thicken beef stroganoff, there are various methods you can use.

Each has its benefits and disadvantages, which are listed below. Steak stroganoff is typically thickened with milk or sour cream.

However, this can change the taste of your final dish quite a bit depending on what ingredients you use, so it is best to experiment by trying different methods until you get one that works well.

1. Add More Thickening Agents

The following methods are commonly used to thicken beef stroganoff:

You may need to add more flour. You can thicken beef stroganoff by adding more flour without changing its flavor or texture too much.

You may increase the amount but it will turn grainy and clumpy if you do. Make sure you add more liquid.

While your beef stroganoff is simmering or boiling, add more stock to help thicken the sauce without changing its flavor too much.

2. Use Egg Yolks Instead of Milk or Cream

Using egg yolks as thickeners when making beef stroganoff is also an option.

Beef stroganoff can be thickened in this way to create a creamy, rich sauce without changing out the taste too much.

Following are some simple steps you can take to prepare egg yolks as an effective thickening agent:

From the beef stroganoff, remove the cooked meat and set it aside.

Put the heat source on high and keep stirring the sauce with a wooden spoon or whisk while adding the egg yolks.

The egg yolks must thicken slightly before the cooked meat can be added back to the sauce.

Stir everything until it’s all heated through, then serve right away.

3. Use Corn Starch as a Thicken Agent

Beef stroganoff can be thickened with corn starch, though this is not a very popular method.

It works best if you add corn starch to your other thickening agents or just use corn starch.

4. Add More Ingredients

Additionally, you can increase the thickness of beef stroganoff by using other ingredients.

Sour cream, for example, can help thicken your mixture without changing its taste significantly if you add it while simmering.

Another ingredient that can be used for this purpose is onion.

By adding onion to your sauce while it is cooking, you will add flavor and help thicken your dish.

5. Create a Roux Base

Roux is another thickening agent that can be used in beef stroganoff.

It is used in dishes such as gumbo, and it works by mixing flour with some type of fat to create an emulsion.

This mixture will be used to thicken your beef stroganoff.

The reason why roux bases are popular is that they thicken the sauce without changing its texture or taste.

6. Simply Let it Simmer

If you simmer beef stroganoff for a long time without thickeners, the gravy will become thicker.

You must be careful to not let the sauce boil too long, as it will turn very dry and crumble if you let it simmer for too long.

Getting a perfect consistency may take some trial and error, but this method is still good for experimenting.


The Beef Stroganoff dish is a popular dish loved by everyone.

However, some people prefer beef stroganoff thickened to make the dish creamier.

The following methods are some of the ways you can accomplish this.

When used properly and experimented with constantly, these methods will all benefit you in the long run.

If you want to read more about cooking, read here: Cooking Tips and Tricks.

Ayub Khan

Ayub Khan is an accomplished culinary author with a passion for cooking and 6 years of experience. His creative ideas and valuable tips inspire readers to explore new flavors and take their culinary skills to the next level.

Rehmat Dietitian

Rehmat is a certified food dietitian having experience of 10 years in reviewing and practicing on foods different aspects.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button